Terahertz Radiation
Terahertz radiation, also referred to as far-infrared radiation, is loosely defined
as the region of the electromagnetic spectrum which lies between 100
GHz and 10 THz. This equates to a wavelength range
of 3 mm to 30 μm
or more appropriately for band structure engineered devices, in terms of energy,
is approximately 0.4-40 meV. Often referred to as
the terahertz ‘gap’ due to the few available sources, as it is the region
where the two approaches for generating electromagnetic radiation meet - optical
devices and electronics, shown in Figure 1. Terahertz frequencies are considered
extremely high for electronics, demanding modulation speeds that push current device
technology that is typically limited to the GHz range by the circuit resistance-capacitance
product. At the opposing end of the scale, the majority of optical sources operate
above 10 THz. With band structure engineered semiconductors,
it is the creation of very low energy radiative transitions that is particularly
challenging.
Figure 1: The terahertz region of the electromagnetic spectrum lies between the
approach of electronic and optical devices1.
As terahertz technology matures, new applications continue to be realised. This
section contains an overview of the major applications driving the research in this
field.
Biomedical Imaging
The non-ionising nature of the far-infrared lends itself to safe biomedical in vivo
imaging. It is thought that the strong attenuation of the radiation by water is
the mechanism which produces the required contrast to allow the identification of
skin cancer (containing a higher density of cells and therefore also water) from
healthy tissue2. Furthermore, different imaging regimes
are available. A reflection measurement (time of flight) can yield quite different
data to an absorption measurement3. Figure 2 depicts
examples of such biomedical applications.
(a) Diagnosis of basal cell carcinoma 2.
|
|
(b) A human tooth in different imaging regimes 3.
|
Figure 2: Biomedical terahertz imaging.
Images courtesy TeraView Ltd.
Industrial & Security Imaging
The time domain nature of Terahertz Pulsed Imaging (TPI) makes three dimensional
imaging possible by recording depth information as a result of reflection from intermediate
surfaces4. Figure 3 shows TPI images of slices through
a packaged integrated chip5. Conventional analysis of this
type could not be done on a production line and would render the chip inoperable.
Additionally, this form of non-destructive evaluation applies equally to large scale
integration of devices present on the wafer before packaging6.
Figure 3: Slices through a packaged integrated chip by terahertz pulsed imaging5.
Image courtesy TeraView Ltd.
The same technology is also applicable to personnel imaging for security purposes
(for example at airports). Where x-rays are unsuitable for routinely imaging people,
TPI has the capability to detect not only concealed metals but ceramics7.
Figure 4 shows a terahertz image of a metal blade and ceramic disc from two different
aspects, concealed in a synthetic fleece pocket.
Figure 4: Terahertz imaging of a metal blade and ceramic disc in a synthetic fleece
pocket7. Image courtesy TeraView Ltd.
Spectroscopy
Far infrared wavelengths cover the vibrational and rotational modes of numerous
molecules, making terahertz radiation suitable for a number of spectroscopy and
sensing applications in the environment. Possibly the most financially lucrative
applications are those involving pharmaceuticals and security screening. Terahertz
spectroscopy has been shown to distinguish between different drug polymorphs8,
aiding pharmaceutical research and patent filings, as well as possible uses in quality
control of tablet coatings9. The detection and identification
of explosives10, as well as chemical and biological
warfare agents such as sarin11
and anthrax12
have been uniquely identified by terahertz spectroscopy. Figure 5 depicts examples
of such spectroscopy based applications.
(a) Explosives spectra 10.
|
|
(b) Sarin and Soman nerve agents 11.
|
Figure 5: Examples of terahertz
spectroscopy.
Sources
An overview of methods for generating terahertz radiation is given below. The discussion
is by no means exhaustive, but includes the dominant technologies with an outline
of the principle of operation for each.
Backward Wave Oscillators
Backward Wave Oscillators (BWOs) produce coherent photon emission by using electrons
bunched in cyclotron motion under a large magnetic field within a vacuum tube. These
devices emit at the lower end of the terahertz range, up to around 1.5
THz13, with output powers up to 12
mW14. Tuning over a narrow range is possible by varying
the electron energy. BWOs principally operate in CW and are most often employed
in spectroscopy applications. BWO systems are custom built and non-portable due
to power supply requirements and fragile vacuum tubes, hence they are confined to
scientific research. Furthermore, they have a limited lifespan, typically below
500 hours of operation.
Direct Multiplied Sources
Direct Multiplied (DM) sources take a sub-millimetre wave input and performs frequency
multiplication to terahertz levels by means of a biased GaAs crystal embedded within
an appropriate waveguide. Commercially available DM sources are very compact, just
inches in length. Moreover, the sources operate at around 100
K, further aiding portability by the possibility for closed-cycle or Peltier cooling.
Like the BWO, performance increases at lower frequencies. At the limit of 2 THz, 1 μW is possible,
but at half this frequency powers increase by an order of magnitude15.
DM sources are most commonly used as local oscillators in heterodyne detector systems.
Non-Linear Optical Methods
The two main methods for generating terahertz radiation via non-linear optical crystals
are optical rectification and difference frequency generation (also known as frequency
mixing or photomixing).
Photoconductive antenna are a method of optical rectification. They are room temperature,
broadband terahertz emitters, operating between approximately 0.3 and 30
THz16
with peak powers of 1 μW17.
They are the most common device for terahertz emission, usually found in time domain
spectroscopy applications such as those discussed above.
The device consists of a pair of metallic stripe contacts patterned on the surface
of a sample of low temperature grown gallium arsenide (LT-GaAs). This antenna is
subjected to an above bandgap laser pulse (typically 1
μm in wavelength from a Ti:Sapphire laser) of less than 100
fs, generating an electron-hole pair. The bias applied to the antenna (typically
tens of volts) rapidly accelerates the carriers to produce a pulse of terahertz
radiation. Output powers are therefore low due to the short interaction length carriers
have between antenna contacts.
The frequency mixing method has a similar physical arrangement to that of the photoconductive
antenna, but quite different properties. Instead of an expensive femtosecond laser,
two laser beams are mixed to create a beat frequency on a single crystal photomixer.
By tuning one of the beams, tunability in the terahertz is possible. Using a gallium
selenide crystal with a sufficiently powerful Nd:YAG laser, peak powers of almost
70 W have been demonstrated with wide tunability
of 0.2-5.3 THz18. Unlike
the photoconductive antenna, operation is narrow band and CW operation is possible.
Optically Pumped Terahertz Lasers
Recent years have seen Optically Pumped Terahertz Lasers (OPTLs) progress from unstable
bespoke systems to highly reliable, commercially available bench-top products. Lasing
occurs between molecular rotational transitions in a low pressure gas cell, usually
pumped by a 9-11 μm CO2 laser. Whilst
discrete tuning is possible, it is done via the inelegant process of changing the
pressure of the cell or the gas itself. CW operation is possible, with output in
the range 0.4-8 THz and peak powers up to 180 mW19. Typical efficiency
is less than 0.1 % resulting in significant heat
loading requiring liquid coolant. Highly tuned systems have however managed to increase
efficiency marginally, to around 1%20.
p-Germanium Laser
The p-type germanium (p-Ge) laser offers tunable coherent output in the range 1-4 THz with relatively high powers up to 10
W21. Population inversion occurs between either two
light-hole Landau levels or a light-hole and heavy-hole subband. A strong magnetic
field (of the order of one Tesla) is required to lift the valence band degeneracy,
crossed with an electric field (around 2 kV
cm-1) for charge pumping. Such a system is easily perturbed by phonon
scattering, thus operation is limited to 4.2 K or
below, with performance rapidly decreasing at higher temperatures. The heat loading
in the germanium crystal further compounds this problem and limits the laser to
relatively short pulse lengths (tens of microseconds) and slow repetition rates
(tens of kHz).
Developments on semi-portable systems with permanent magnets and requiring no liquid
helium supply22,23
have proved promising but performance is lacking. Primarily the requirement for
liquid helium (an expensive commodity) and the bulk of a pulsed magnet system confines
this laser to institutions dedicated to terahertz research.
Silicon Impurity
State Laser
The silicon impurity state laser consists of a n-type silicon crystal doped around
1015 cm-3 which is optically
pumped by a CO2 laser. Depending on the dopant used, a number of discrete
wavelengths are available: 5.4 THz for phosphorus,
5.2 THz for antimony, 5.9 and 6.6
THz for arsenic and 5.8, 6.2 and 6.4 THz for bismuth.
A small degree of tuning (tens of GHz) is however possible by the application of
a magnetic field or strain. The relatively long-lived impurity states facilitate
population inversion, but the resonant phonon-assisted relaxation employed in these
systems is quickly degraded by thermal energy. Operation is therefore limited to
pulsed mode, below approximately 20 K, with powers
up to tens of milliwatts24.
Free Electron Laser
First demonstrated in 197725, free electron lasers account
for the most powerful and tunable terahertz sources. However, the size, cost and
complexity of such lasers confines them to major research institutes. As of 2004,
there were only 43 operational free electron lasers in the world, with a further
25 proposed or under construction over the next decade26.
The technology is described in detail in Chapter~\ref{chp:lifetimes}, however an
outline of the principle is as follows. A relativistic beam of electrons is injected
through a periodically varying magnetic field, within an optical resonant cavity.
Photon emission is produced by the transverse deflection of the electron, similar
to the principle of the dipole antenna. The properties of such lasers make possible
very high output powers and a large wavelength range of operation. The highest CW
power achieved in the far infrared to date is 10
kW, with similar systems providing high power lasing from 10
nm (x-rays)27
to 10 mm (microwaves)28. The
free electron laser has been shown to be a very scalable system. At many facilities
work is ongoing to push operation to extreme powers (terawatts), wavelengths (sub-nanometre)
and pulse duration (sub-femtosecond)29, although not
all in the same system.
Quantum Cascade Lasers
The Quantum Cascade Laser (QCL) is the most modern, compact and convenient terahertz
source and has recently become commercially available30,31.
QCLs based upon III-V alloys have shown lasing from 3.4
μm32
to 161 μm33
and show great promise in realising the applications discussed above.
Being the subject of this work, a detailed discussion of the technology follows
in a
later section.
- 1http://www.brukeroptics.comBruker Optics Inc.
- 2Terahertz pulse imaging of ex vivo basal cell carcinomaR M Woodward, V P Wallace, R J Pye, B E Cole, D D Arnone, E H Linfield, M PepperJournal of Investigative Dematology, 120(1), 72-78
- 3Three-dimensional terahertz pulse imaging of dental tissueD Crawley, C Longbottom, V P Wallace, B E Cole, D D Arnone, M PepperJournal of Biomedical Optics, 8(2), 303-307
- 4Towards functional 3D T-ray imagingB Ferguson, S Wang, D Gray, D Abbott, X-C ZhangPhysics in Medicine and Biology, 47(21), 3735-3742
- 5Terahertz sensors for explosives detection and other security applicationsM Kemp
- 6Imaging of large-scale integrated circuits using laser terahertz emission microscopyM Yamashita, K Kawase, C Otani, T Kiwa, M TonouchiOptics Express, 13(1), 115-120
- 7http://www.teraview.co.uk/ap_security.aspTeraview Ltd.
- 8Using terahertz pulse spectroscopy to study the crystalline structure of a drug: A case study of the polymorphs of ranitidine hydrochlorideP F Taday, I V Bradley, D D Arnone, M PepperJournal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, 92(4), 831-838
- 9Nondestructive analysis of tablet coating thicknesses using terahertz pulsed imagingA J Fitzgerald, B E Cole, P F TadayJournal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, 94(1), 177-183
- 10Detection and identification of explosives using terahertz pulsed spectroscopic imagingY C Shen, T Lo, P F Taday, B E Cole, W R Tribe, M C KempApplied Physics Letters, 86(24), 241116
- 11Fourier-transform microwave spectroscopy of chemical-warfare agents and their synthetic precursorsA R Hight-Walker, R D Suenram, A Samuels, J Jensen, D Woolard, W WiebachSPIE Proceedings: Air monitoring and detection of chemical and biological agents, 3533(), 122-127
- 12Secondary structure of anthrax lethal toxin proteins and their interaction with large unilamellar vesicles: A Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy approachX M Wang, M Mock, J M Ruysschaert, V CabiauxBiochemistry, 35(47), 14939-14946
- 13Terahertz BWO-spectrosopyB Gorshunov, A Volkov, I Spektor, A Prokhorov, A Mukhin, M Dressel, A Uchida, A LoidlInternational Journal of Infrared And Millimeter Waves, 26(9), 1217-1240
- 14Comparison between pulsed terahertz time-domain imaging and continuous wave terahertz imagingN Karpowicz, H Zhong, J Xu, K-I Lin, J-S Hwang, X-C ZhangSemiconductor Science and Technology, 20(7), S293-S299
- 15Development and characterization of an easy-to-use THz sourceJ Hesler, D Porterfield, W Bishop, T Crowe, A Baryshev, R Hesper, J Baselmans
- 16Ultrabroadband terahertz radiation from low-temperature-grown GaAs photoconductive emittersY C Shen, P C Upadhya, E H Linfield, H E Beere, A G DaviesApplied Physics Letters, 83(15), 3117-3119
- 17Ultrafast dynamical processes in semiconductorsJ Shan, T F Heinz
- 18Efficient, tunable, and coherent 0.18-5.27-THz source based on GaSe crystalW Shi, Y J Ding, N Fernelius, K VodopyanovOptics Letters, 27(16), 1454-1456
- 19http://www.coherent.com/lasers/Coherent Inc.
- 20Stable 1.25 Watts CW far infrared laser radiation at the 119 μm methanol lineJ Farhoomand, H M PickettInternational Journal of Infrared and Millimeter Waves, 8(5), 441-447
- 21Long-wavelength infrared semiconductor lasersH K Choi
- 22First operation of a far-infrared p-germanium laser in a standard close-cycle machine at 15KE Brundermann, H P RoserInfrared Physics & Technology, 38(4), 201-203
- 23http://www.zaubertek.comZaubertek Inc.
- 24Terahertz lasers based on germanium and siliconH-W Hübers, S G Pavlov, V N ShastinSemiconductor Science and Technology, 20(7), S211-S221
- 25First operation of a free-electron laserD A G Deacon, L R Elias, J M J Madey, G J Ramian, H A Schwettman, T I SmithPhysics Review Letters, 38(16), 892-894
- 26Free electron lasers in 2004W B Colson, B W Williams
- 27First operation of a free-electron laser generating GW power radiation at 32nm wavelengthV Ayvazyan, N Baboi, J Bahr, V Balandin, B Beutner, A Brandt, I Bohnet, A Bolzmann, R Brinkmann, O I Brovko, J P Carneiro, S Casalbuoni, M Castellano, P Castro, L Catani, E Chiadroni, S Choroba, A Cianchi, H Delsim-Hashemi, G Di Pirro, M Dohlus, S Dusterer, H T Edwards, B Faatz, A A Fateev, J Feldhaus, K Flottmann, J Frisch, L Frohlich, T Garvey, U Gensch, N Golubeva, H-J Grabosch, B Grigoryan, O Grimm, U Hahn, J H Han, M V Hartrott, K Honkavaara, M Huning, R Ischebeck, E Jaeschke, M Jablonka, R Kammering, V Katalev, B Keitel, S Khodyachykh, Y Kim, V Kocharyan, M Korfer, M Kollewe, D Kostin, D Kramer, M Krassilnikov, G Kube, L Lilje, T Limberg, D Lipka, F Lohl, M Luong, C Magne, J Menzel, P Michelato, V Miltchev, M Minty, W D Molller, L Monaco, W Muller, M Nagl, O Napoly, P Nicolosi, D Nolle, T Nunez, A Oppelt, C Pagani, R Paparella, B Petersen, B Petrosyan, J Pfluger, P Piot, E Plonjes, L Poletto, D Proch, D Pugachov, K Rehlich, D Richter, S Riemann, M Ross, J Rossbach, M Sachwitz, E L Saldin, W Sandner, H Schlarb, B Schmidt, M Schmitz, P Schmuser, J R Schneider, E A Schneidmiller, H-J Schreiber, S Schreiber, A V Shabunov, D Sertore, S Setzer, S Simrock, E Sombrowski, L Staykov, B Steffen, F Stephan, F Stulle, K P Sytchev, H Thom, K Tiedtke, M Tischer, R Treusch, D Trines, I Tsakov, A Vardanyan, R Wanzenberg, T Weiland, H Weise, M Wendt, I Will, A Winter, K Wittenburg, M V Yurkov, I Zagorodnov, P Zambolin, K ZapfeThe European Physical Journal D, 37(2), 297-303
- 28First lasing of the KAERI millimeter-wave free electron laserB C Lee, S K Kim, Y U Jeong, S O Cho, B H Cha, J LeeNuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 375(1-3), 28-31
- 29Terawatt-scale sub-10-fs laser technology - key to generation of GW-level attosecond pulses in X-ray free electron laserE L Saldin, E A Schneidmiller, M V YurkovOptics Communications, 237(1-3), 153-164
- 30http://www.alpeslasers.chAlpes Lasers SA
- 31http://www.cascade-technologies.comCascade Technologies Ltd.
- 32Short wavelength (λ ∼ 3.4 μm) quantum cascade laser based on strained compensated InGaAs/AlInAsJ Faist, F Capasso, D L Sivco, A L Hutchinson, S-N G Chu, A Y ChoApplied Physics Letters, 72(6), 680-682
- 331.9 THz quantum-cascade lasers with one-well injectorS Kumar, B S Williams, Q Hu, J L RenoApplied Physics Letters, 88(12), 121123